#1reasonwhy I Have a Problem with Deponia (and other stuff)

7 thoughts on “#1reasonwhy I Have a Problem with Deponia (and other stuff)”

  1. Definitely think there are some good points raised in this article, although I think it just demonstrates misunderstanding on your behalf to say that able-bodied or able-minded people find disability ‘funny’. Hilariously, Bugs Bunny is well known for saying “What a moron!”, and ‘moron’ is a word that was previously used as a formal term for a form of intellectual disability. In other words, the exact example you described as unthinkable and vulgar literally exists, just with language you personally find less offensive. When people laugh at these lines and the comedy that accompanies them, they’re laughing at stupidity, and whatever word is used to describe that is arbitrary. To me, seeing that as offensive would be like taking offence to someone saying “Are you blind?” to their socially oblivious friend, or “Are you deaf?” to someone not paying attention. If you were saying that being blind or deaf made you a burden, a worse person, or some other barbaric thing, certainly this is something to object to. But this isn’t what these sayings do. I think it’s very harmful to imply stuff like this is ‘ableism’ (if you will), because it shifts the focus away from the mother telling her child not to play with the autistic kid in the schoolyard to something with debatable consequences (that said, there are definitely still instances where using words like ‘retard’ are grossly inappropriate and derogatory, just this isn’t one of them).

    On a separate point, I always thought that the whole point of the ‘sexism’ and ‘transphobia’ and whatnot in Deponia was meant to be satire, as with the homeless man. I mean, the female lead is literally called ‘Goal’ for Christ sake, like she’s literally the goal of the game. Given how much Rufus judges things using surface-deep labels which have no ultimate grounding in reality, I thought having the love interest’s name being ‘Goal’ was worth a chuckle, once I realised the joke. I thought the main power from the game, in this area, came from how nothing in the game works like the bizarre fairy-tale version of it which Rufus has in his head. It specifically says “This is what an adventure game protagonist in a sexist, judgemental game would think, and look how at odds that puts him with the real world.”. Mind you, you already made a similar point, so it looks like we just draw the line at what it or isn’t satire at different points.

    I definitely agree that there are forms of sexism in games that aren’t acceptable, but I think the whole point of Deponia is subverting that. Having a protagonist who views Goal as a literal ‘goal’ before developing a genuine, rich connection with chemistry is not only satire, but says something meaningful about gender roles in videogames, I think.

    Definitely late to the party in responding to this article, but still thought this was a worthwhile response to make. Hope I get a chance to hear your thoughts on it, Mark! You wrote an article worth the read!

  2. So exactly as you said with disability,which is funny to the able people(not my case though) it’s funny for you because you are a man and you don’t suffer it. I’m a woman and I can’t find it funny I find it depressing. Another depressing thing is a man who calls himself a feminist and says the atrocities you wrote in this article justifying the unforgivable. Gross.

  3. I finished playing all three games, and was pleasantly surprised. Without spoiling too much of the third game, the developers clearly became a little bit more self-aware of their writing, and Lotti returns in the third game as a pretty badass character (albeit still in a minor role), and while the stupid voice quips are there, Rufus makes no transphobic remarks about her this time around and treats her as normal; her voice became less of a joke but rather more of keeping with the continuity (which shouldn’t have happened in the first place). Also Rufus gets what’s coming to him by the end, so that’s cool. I really liked the trilogy overall, and while it is kind of problematic it didn’t deter my enjoyment of it.

    1. I don’t know if it’s unlucky of you to have bought them or even if you enjoy them. There’s content there to be enjoyed, it’s just that there are problems to think abut while you enjoy them. :)

Leave a Reply to bobby2643 Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s